First Court of Appeals

Case: 01-07-00431-CV    
01-07-00431-CV
05/18/2007
Summary judgment
Brookshire Katy Drainage District 
The Lily Gardens, LLC, Richard E. Fluecker and Kenneth B. Luedecke 
No 
 
 
 
 
 
Thomson/West 
Appellate Briefs
Date▲▼Event Type▲▼Description▲▼Document
09/21/2009Reply brief filedAppellant
04/02/2009Amicus curiae brief receivedAmicus Curiae
03/19/2009Supplemental brief filedAppellant
02/13/2009Amicus curiae brief receivedAmicus Curiae
01/06/2009Amicus curiae brief receivedAmicus Curiae
10/31/2008Amicus curiae brief receivedAmicus Curiae
10/30/2008Amicus curiae brief receivedAmicus Curiae
10/29/2008Reply brief filedAppellee
10/23/2008Supplemental brief filedAmicus Curiae
07/21/2008Amicus curiae brief receivedAmicus Curiae
04/25/2008Reply brief filedAppellee
03/28/2008Reply brief filedAppellant
03/07/2008Brief filed - oral argument not requestedAppellee
11/08/2007Brief filed - oral argument requestedAppellant
Case Events
Date▲▼Event Type▲▼Disposition▲▼Document
06/04/2012Mandate issued 
04/25/2012Letter filed 
04/06/2012Notice received 
02/28/2012Notice received 
02/28/2012Notice received 
02/14/2012Notice received 
02/13/2012Notice received 
04/01/2011Sent to publisher 
03/31/2011Petition for review filed in Supreme Court 
02/25/2011Opinion issuedOpinion dissenting to this Court's judgment
[ HTML/32 KB ] Dissenting Opinion
[ PDF/139 KB ] Dissenting Opinion
02/25/2011Opinion issuedOpinion concurring with this Court's judgment
[ HTML/65 KB ] Concurring Opinion
[ PDF/143 KB ] Concurring Opinion
02/25/2011Opinion issuedOpinion concurring with this Court's judgment
[ HTML/52 KB ] Concurring Opinion
[ PDF/95 KB ] Concurring Opinion
02/25/2011Opinion issuedOpinion dissenting to this Court's judgment
[ HTML/21 KB ] Dissenting Opinion
[ PDF/254 KB ] Dissenting Opinion
02/25/2011Motion for en banc reconsideration disposedDeny motion
02/22/2011Motion for extension of time to file response disposedDismiss motion
01/26/2011Response filed 
01/24/2011Opposition filed 
01/18/2011Fee paid 
01/18/2011Motion for extension of time to file response filed 
01/17/2011Response due 
12/29/2010Motion for extension of time to file response disposedGrant motion
12/17/2010Fee paid 
12/17/2010Motion for extension of time to file response filed 
12/01/2010Response requested by the court 
10/11/2010Fee paid 
10/11/2010Motion for en banc reconsideration filed 
10/11/2010Motion for rehearing due 
10/08/2010Motion for extension of time to file motion for rehearing enbanc disposedGrant motion
09/28/2010Fee paid 
09/28/2010Motion for extension of time to file motion for rehearing enbanc filed 
09/25/2010Motion for rehearing due 
09/10/2010Opinion issuedOpinion dissenting to this Court's judgment
[ HTML/35 KB ] Dissenting Opinion
[ PDF/72 KB ] Dissenting Opinion
09/10/2010Opinion issuedAffirm TC judgment
09/10/2010Judgment Issued 
09/10/2010Motion for rehearing grantedGrant motion
06/14/2010Reply to response or motion filed 
06/10/2010Reply brief due 
06/07/2010Reply to response or motion filed 
05/27/2010Order enteredIssue sua sponte order
02/05/2010Motion for rehearing filed 
02/05/2010Fee paid 
02/05/2010Motion for rehearing due 
01/12/2010Motion for extension of time to file motion for rehearing disposedGrant motion
01/06/2010Fee paid 
01/06/2010Motion for extension of time to file motion for rehearing filed 
01/06/2010Motion for rehearing due 
12/22/2009Judgment withdrawnVacate this Court's judgment
12/22/2009Memorandum opinion withdrawnWithdraw this Court's opinion
12/22/2009Judgment Issued 
12/22/2009Memorandum opinion issuedReverse TC judgment and remand case to TC for further proceedings
[ HTML/30 KB ] Memorandum Opinion
[ PDF/133 KB ] Memorandum Opinion
11/19/2009Letter issued by the court 
10/29/2009Response received 
09/21/2009Reply brief filed 
09/01/2009Submitted 
09/01/2009Case reinstated 
04/16/2009Order issuedAbate case
04/15/2009Deadline to conduct mediation 
04/02/2009Amicus curiae brief received 
03/27/2009Order enteredGrant motion
03/19/2009Supplemental brief filed 
03/14/2009Deadline for parties to select mediator 
03/12/2009Mediation objection filed 
03/11/2009Corrected pages to opinion issued 
02/27/2009Order withdrawn 
02/27/2009Order enteredMediation
02/24/2009Submitted 
02/20/2009Motion to reconsider disposedDeny motion
02/17/2009Response filed 
02/13/2009Amicus curiae brief received 
02/12/2009Response filed 
02/11/2009Fee paid 
02/11/2009Motion to reconsider filed 
02/03/2009Set for submission on briefs - oral argument denied 
01/06/2009Amicus curiae brief received 
12/16/2008Motion to strike disposedDeny motion
12/16/2008Motion disposedGrant motion
11/20/2008Motion filed 
10/31/2008Amicus curiae brief received 
10/30/2008Amicus curiae brief received 
10/29/2008Reply brief filed 
10/23/2008Response filed 
10/23/2008Supplemental brief filed 
10/10/2008Response requested by the court 
10/07/2008Fee paid 
10/03/2008Motion to strike filed 
07/21/2008Amicus curiae brief received 
05/09/2008Response filed 
05/02/2008Motion to strike disposedMotion will be taken with case
04/28/2008Motion to strike filed 
04/28/2008Fee paid 
04/25/2008Reply brief filed 
03/28/2008Reply brief filed 
03/25/2008Motion to file amended brief disposedGrant motion
03/12/2008Motion to amend filed 
03/12/2008Fee paid 
03/07/2008Brief filed - oral argument not requested 
03/07/2008Case ready to be set 
03/07/2008Appellees brief due 
02/14/2008Motion for extension of time to file brief disposedGrant motion
02/12/2008Reply to response or motion filed 
02/08/2008Response filed 
02/07/2008Motion for extension of time to file brief filed 
02/07/2008Fee paid 
02/06/2008Appellees brief due 
01/10/2008Motion for extension of time to file brief disposedGrant motion
01/07/2008Motion for extension of time to file brief filed 
01/07/2008Fee paid 
01/07/2008Record checked in 
01/07/2008Appellees brief due 
01/03/2008Record checked out 
12/17/2007Motion for extension of time to file brief disposedGrant motion
12/10/2007Motion for extension of time to file brief filed 
12/10/2007Fee paid 
12/08/2007Appellees brief due 
11/08/2007Motion for extension of time to file brief disposedGrant motion
11/08/2007Brief filed - oral argument requested 
11/02/2007Record checked in 
11/01/2007Motion for extension of time to file brief filed 
11/01/2007Fee paid 
10/17/2007Appellants brief due 
09/26/2007Motion for extension of time to file brief disposedGrant motion
09/21/2007Fee paid 
09/18/2007Motion for extension of time to file brief filed 
09/17/2007Appellants brief due 
08/28/2007Motion for extension of time to file brief disposedGrant motion
08/22/2007Fee paid 
08/17/2007Motion for extension of time to file brief filed 
08/17/2007Record checked out 
08/17/2007Appellants brief due 
07/18/2007Reporters record filed 
07/17/2007Reporters record filed 
07/03/2007Reporters record filed 
07/03/2007Record due 
06/19/2007Clerks record filed 
06/07/2007Court fee due 
06/05/2007Court reporters information sheet sent 
06/02/2007Docketing statement due 
05/31/2007Letter filed 
05/30/2007Docketing statement filed 
05/30/2007Fee paid 
05/18/2007Notice of appeal received 
05/18/2007Case began in court of appeals 
05/16/2007Notice of appeal filed in trial court 
05/04/2007Judgment signed by trial court judge 
Calendars
Set Date▲▼Calendar Type▲▼Reason Set▲▼
06/04/2018RetentionDate civil case will be destroyed (6 yrs after mandate)
Parties
Party▲▼Party Type▲▼Representative▲▼
Luedecke, Kenneth B.AppelleeLevon G. Hovnatanian
Raul H. Suazo
Brookshire Katy Drainage DistrictAppellantKevin D. Jewell
William Helfand
David Frishman
Fluecker, Richard E.AppelleeDale Jefferson
Raul H. Suazo
Levon G. Hovnatanian
The Lily Gardens, LLCAppelleeLevon G. Hovnatanian
Raul H. Suazo
Trial Court Information
9th District Court 
Waller 
Honorable Hon. Frederick Edwards 
060818415