First Court of Appeals

Case: 01-08-00179-CV    
01-08-00179-CV
03/10/2008
Summary judgment
Angela Mae Brannan, Individually and as Independent Executrix of the Estate of Bob Albert Brannan, Deceased, et al 
The State of Texas, The Village of Surfside Beach, Mayor Larry Davison, and Surfrider Foundation 
No 
 
 
 
 
 
www.txcourts.gov/1stcoa 
Appellate Briefs
Date▲▼Event Type▲▼Description▲▼Document
12/18/2013Reply brief filedAppellant
11/20/2013Brief filed - oral argument not requestedAppellee
11/14/2013Brief filed - oral argument requestedAppellee
11/14/2013Brief filed - oral argument not requestedAppellee
09/10/2013Brief filed - oral argument requestedAppellant
06/25/2009Letter brief filedAppellant
06/18/2009Letter brief filedAppellee
04/10/2009Post submission brief filedAppellee
04/10/2009Supplemental brief filedAppellant
04/10/2009Post submission brief filedAppellee
01/22/2009Reply brief filedAppellant
12/29/2008Brief filed - oral argument requestedAppellee
12/12/2008Brief filed - oral argument requestedAppellee
09/17/2008Brief filed - oral argument requestedAppellant
Case Events
Date▲▼Event Type▲▼Disposition▲▼Document
12/31/2007Motion for new trial was filed in the trial court 
12/29/2008Case ready to be set 
12/29/2008Brief filed - oral argument requested 
12/23/2008Appellees brief due 
12/19/2013Motion for extension of time to file brief disposedMotion or Writ Granted
12/19/2013Motion for extension of time to file reply brief disposedMotion or Writ Granted
12/18/2013Motion for extension of time to file reply brief filed 
[ PDF/17 KB ] Extension
12/18/2013Reply brief filed 
12/16/2013Reply brief due 
12/15/2008Motion to exceed brief length disposedGrant motion
12/12/2008Motion for extension of time to file brief disposedGrant motion
12/12/2008Brief filed - oral argument requested 
12/10/2013Reply brief due 
12/10/2008Fee paid 
12/10/2008Motion to exceed brief length filed 
12/09/2008Motion for extension of time to file brief filed 
12/08/2008Fee paid 
12/07/2007Judgment signed by trial court judge 
12/03/2008Motion for extension of time to file brief disposedGrant motion
12/01/2014Document filed 
11/27/2008Appellees brief due 
11/25/2008Motion for extension of time to file brief filed 
11/20/2013Motion for extension of time to file reply brief filed 
[ PDF/26 KB ] Extension
11/20/2013Brief filed - oral argument not requested 
11/20/2013Case ready to be set 
11/18/2008Fee paid 
11/18/2008Motion filed 
11/17/2008Appellees brief due 
11/15/2013Appellees brief due 
11/14/2013Brief filed - oral argument requested 
11/14/2013Brief filed - oral argument not requested 
11/14/2013Appellees brief due 
11/14/2013Appellees brief due 
11/13/2009Letter filed 
10/28/2010Case forwarded to higher court 
10/23/2009Response filed 
10/23/2009Response due 
10/23/2008Motion for extension of time to file brief disposedGrant motion
10/17/2008Motion for extension of time to file brief filed 
10/17/2008Appellees brief due 
10/10/2013Appellees brief due 
10/10/2008Motion for extension of time to file brief disposedGrant motion
10/09/2013Motion for extension of time to file brief disposedMotion or Writ Granted
10/09/2013Motion for extension of time to file brief disposedMotion or Writ Granted
10/09/2013Motion for extension of time to file brief filed 
[ PDF/95 KB ] Extension
10/08/2013Motion for extension of time to file brief filed 
[ PDF/80 KB ] Extension
10/08/2008Record checked in 
10/06/2008Fee paid 
10/06/2008Motion for extension of time to file brief filed 
10/04/2013Motion for extension of time to file brief disposedMotion or Writ Granted
10/03/2013Motion for extension of time to file brief filed 
[ PDF/83 KB ] Extension
10/01/2009Motion for extension of time to file response disposedGrant motion
09/30/2009Response due 
09/25/2009Motion for extension of time to file response filed 
09/23/2013Letter filed 
09/18/2013Notice filed 
09/18/2013Notice filed 
[ PDF/76 KB ] Amended Notice
09/18/2009Response requested by the court 
09/18/2009Letter received 
09/17/2008Brief filed - oral argument requested 
09/15/2008Appellants brief due 
09/12/2009Motion for rehearing due 
09/11/2009Fee paid 
09/11/2009Fee paid 
09/11/2009Motion for rehearing en banc filed 
09/11/2009Motion for rehearing filed 
09/11/2008Record checked out 
09/10/2013Brief filed - oral argument requested 
09/10/2013Appellants brief due 
09/08/2008Record checked in 
09/08/2008Record checked in 
09/05/2013Appearance of counsel 
[ PDF/64 KB ] Notice of Appearance
08/28/2009Judgment withdrawn 
08/28/2009Opinion withdrawn 
08/28/2009Opinion issuedAffirm TC judgment
08/28/2009Judgment Issued 
08/28/2009Motion disposedDeny motion
08/23/2013Appellants brief due 
08/15/2008Appellants brief due 
08/14/2008Record checked out 
08/13/2008Fax received 
07/31/2008Motion for extension of time to file brief disposedGrant motion
07/29/2008Reporters record due 
07/28/2008Motion for extension of time to file brief filed 
07/28/2008Fee paid 
07/26/2013Motion for extension of time to file brief disposedMotion or Writ Granted
07/26/2013Motion for extension of time to file brief filed 
[ PDF/26 KB ] Extension
07/25/2008Record checked in 
07/24/2008Exhibits filed 
07/23/2013Motion disposed 
07/21/2008Record checked out 
07/16/2008Reporters record filed 
07/15/2008Record checked in 
07/14/2008Extension of time to file reporters record disposedGrant motion
07/11/2014Mandate issued 
07/09/2008Extension of time to file reporters record filed 
07/08/2008Record checked out 
07/07/2008Reporters record due 
06/26/2008Clerks record filed 
06/25/2009Letter brief filed 
06/22/2008Clerks record due 
06/18/2009Letter brief filed 
06/17/2008Extension of time to file reporters record disposedGrant motion
06/10/2008Extension of time to file reporters record filed 
06/06/2008Reporters record due 
06/05/2013Letter filed 
05/27/2008Extension of time to file clerks record disposedGrant motion
05/22/2008Extension of time to file clerks record filed 
05/16/2014Motion for rehearing was not filed 
05/16/2014Motion for rehearing due 
05/05/2008Clerks record due 
05/01/2014Memorandum opinion issuedReverse TC judgment and remand case to TC for further proceedings
[ PDF/178 KB ] Memorandum Opinion
[ PDF/74 KB ] Notice
05/01/2014Judgment Issued 
05/01/2008Letter filed 
04/21/2010Petition for review due in Supreme Court 
04/20/2010Petition for review filed in Supreme Court 
04/15/2008Extension of time to file reporters record disposedGrant motion
04/11/2013Motion filed 
04/10/2009Post submission brief filed 
04/10/2009Supplemental brief filed 
04/10/2009Post submission brief filed 
04/09/2008Extension of time to file reporters record filed 
04/08/2008Motion to appear pro hac vice disposedGrant motion
04/05/2008Record due 
04/03/2008Extension of time to file clerks record disposedGrant motion
04/01/2008Extension of time to file clerks record filed 
03/31/2009Submitted 
03/31/2008Motion to appear pro hac vice filed 
03/31/2008Fee paid 
03/27/2008Court fee due 
03/24/2008Letter received 
03/22/2008Docketing statement due 
03/21/2008Docketing statement filed 
03/20/2009Letter received 
03/19/2008Fee paid 
03/13/2008Letter received 
03/10/2009Set for submission on oral argument 
03/10/2008Notice of appeal received 
03/10/2008Case began in court of appeals 
03/08/2013Case ready to be set 
03/08/2013Case remanded from higher court 
03/08/2013Case returned from higher court 
03/06/2013Letter filed 
03/02/2010Motion for extension of time to file petition for review disposed by Supreme CourtGrant motion
03/01/2010Motion for extension of time to file petition for review filed in Supreme Court 
02/29/2008Notice of appeal filed in trial court 
02/25/2014Submitted 
02/19/2010Motion for rehearing due 
02/04/2010Judgment Issued 
02/04/2010Opinion issuedAffirm TC judgment
02/04/2010Motion for rehearing en banc disposedDeny motion
02/04/2010Motion for rehearing disposedDeny motion
01/25/2013Letter received 
01/24/2018Exhibits received 
01/22/2009Reply brief filed 
01/20/2009Reply brief due 
01/18/2018Exhibits returned to the district or county clerk 
01/08/2014Set for submission on briefs - oral argument denied 
Calendars
Set Date▲▼Calendar Type▲▼Reason Set▲▼
07/11/2020RetentionDate civil case will be destroyed (6 yrs after mandate)
Parties
Party▲▼Party Type▲▼Representative▲▼
Angela Mae Brannan, Individually and as Independent Executrix of the Estate of Bob Albert Brannan, Deceased, et alAppellantJ. David Breemer
Ted Hirtz
Brannan, KirkAppellantJ. David Breemer
Ted Hirtz
Brannan, Johnnie LucilleAppellantTed Hirtz
J. David Breemer
Palmer, MarcAppellantTed Hirtz
J. David Breemer
Clinton, JudyAppellantJ. David Breemer
Ted Hirtz
Marvin Jacobson Family Holding CompanyAppellantTed Hirtz
J. David Breemer
Pusley, JamesAppellantTed Hirtz
J. David Breemer
Aplin, Inc., Successor at Interest to a Partnership between Beaver Aplin and Reg AplinAppellantJ. David Breemer
Ted Hirtz
Village of Surfside Beach and its Mayor, James BedwardAppelleeGeorge William Vie III
The State of TexasAppelleePriscilla M. Hubenak  
Dyment, JeffreyAppellantJ. David Breemer
Ted Hirtz
Rogers Thomson, Independent Executor of the Estate of P.E. Kinz, DeceasedAppellantJ. David Breemer
Ted Hirtz
Surfrider Foundation Environmental DefenseAppelleeLaura Ruth Jacks
Jefferson E. Boyt  
Porter, MerryAppellantJ. David Breemer
Ted Hirtz
Fuka, Lisa Marie DewittAppellantTed Hirtz
J. David Breemer
S & S Holdings, LLCAppellantTed Hirtz
J. David Breemer
Porter, BrooksAppellantJ. David Breemer
Ted Hirtz
Bullard, LouiseAppellantTed Hirtz
J. David Breemer
Reutzel, AndreaAppellantTed Hirtz
J. David Breemer
Reutzel, KennethAppellantJ. David Breemer
Ted Hirtz
Russell Clinton, Individually and as Administrator of the Estate of Elizabeth Clinton, DeceasedAppellantTed Hirtz
J. David Breemer
Ramirez, MacarioAppellantJ. David Breemer
Ted Hirtz
Loggins Clark, DianneAppellantTed Hirtz
J. David Breemer
Pursley, PatriciaAppellantTed Hirtz
J. David Breemer
Dewitt, Joseph CornellAppellantTed Hirtz
J. David Breemer
Dickerson, ChrissieAppellantJ. David Breemer
Ted Hirtz
Trial Court Information
239th District Court 
Brazoria 
Honorable Judge 239th District Court 
15802 
Terri Sanchez