First Court of Appeals

Case: 01-10-00719-CV    
01-10-00719-CV
08/19/2010
Contract
Controls Solutions, Inc., United Phosphorus, Inc. and Mark Boyd 
Gharda USA, Inc. and Gharda Chemical Ltd. 
No 
 
 
 
 
 
Thomson/West 
Appellate Briefs
Date▲▼Event Type▲▼Description▲▼Document
01/30/2012Letter brief filedAppellee
01/09/2012Post submission brief filedAppellant
11/22/2011Post submission brief filedAppellee
11/02/2011Reply brief filedAppellant
08/11/2011Brief filed - oral argument requestedAppellee
08/10/2011Electronic brief filed - oral argument requestedAppellee
04/11/2011Brief filed - oral argument requestedAppellant
Case Events
Date▲▼Event Type▲▼Disposition▲▼Document
12/21/2010Reporters record filed 
12/20/2010Record checked in 
12/17/2010Record checked out 
12/13/2012Motion for extension of time to file petition for review disposed by Supreme CourtMotion or Writ Granted
12/12/2011Supplemental clerks record filed 
12/11/2010Reporters record due 
12/10/2012Motion for extension of time to file petition for review filed in Supreme Court 
11/30/2010Reporters record filed 
11/29/2012Motion for en banc reconsideration disposedDeny motion
11/29/2012Motion for rehearing disposedDeny motion
11/24/2010Extension of time to file reporters record disposedGrant motion to extend time; absent extraordinary circumstances, Court will not grant additional motions to extend time
11/22/2011Document filed 
11/22/2011Post submission brief filed 
11/19/2010Extension of time to file reporters record filed 
11/18/2011Motion to exceed brief length disposedGrant motion
11/08/2011Submitted 
11/02/2011Motion to exceed brief length filed 
11/02/2011Reply brief filed 
11/01/2011Document filed 
10/30/2011Reply brief due 
10/18/2010Record checked out 
10/17/2011Set for submission on oral argument 
10/13/2010Clerks record filed 
10/11/2010Record due 
10/04/2010Supplemental clerks record filed 
10/03/2014Petition for review disposed by Supreme Court 
09/30/2011Fee paid 
09/30/2011Motion for extension of time to file reply brief filed 
09/30/2011Reply brief due 
09/28/2012Motion for en banc reconsideration filed 
09/28/2012Motion for rehearing filed 
[ PDF/229 KB ] , 9-28-12 Ape's Reh En Banc & Rehearing
09/28/2012Motion for rehearing due 
09/20/2010Court fee due 
09/20/2010Docketing statement due 
09/14/2011Motion for extension of time to file reply brief disposedGrant motion
09/13/2013Case forwarded to higher court 
09/07/2012Appearance of counsel 
08/31/2011Fee paid 
08/31/2011Motion for extension of time to file reply brief filed 
08/30/2011Reply brief due 
08/29/2012Motion for extension of time to file motion for rehearing disposedMotion or Writ Granted
08/26/2010Docketing statement filed 
08/22/2012Motion for extension of time to file motion for rehearing filed 
08/19/2010Notice of appeal received 
08/19/2010Case began in court of appeals 
08/18/2010Fee paid 
08/18/2010Notice of appeal filed in trial court 
08/16/2012Opinion issuedOpinion dissenting to this Court's judgment
[ PDF/359 KB ] Dissenting Opinion
08/16/2012Opinion issuedReverse TC judgment and remand case to TC for further proceedings
08/15/2012Judgment Issued 
08/11/2011Brief filed - oral argument requested 
08/10/2011Electronic brief filed - oral argument requested 
08/10/2011Case ready to be set 
08/10/2011Appellees brief due 
08/10/2010Judgment signed by trial court judge 
07/31/2012Motion for extension of time to file reply brief disposedMotion or Writ Granted
[ PDF ] Notice of Order on Motion
07/21/2011Motion for extension of time to file brief disposedGrant motion
07/21/2011Fee paid 
07/11/2011Appellees brief due 
07/06/2011Motion for extension of time to file brief filed 
06/18/2015Case stored 
06/18/2015Document filed 
[ PDF/143 KB ] Letter
[ PDF/125 KB ] Tx Sup Ct Mandate
05/20/2011Motion for extension of time to file brief disposedGrant motion to extend time; absent extraordinary circumstances, Court will not grant additional motions to extend time
05/11/2011Appellees brief due 
05/08/2015Document filed 
[ PDF/146 KB ] Letter
[ PDF/8 KB ] Tx Sup Ct Judgment
[ PDF/132 KB ] Tx Sup Ct Opinion
05/06/2011Fee paid 
05/06/2011Motion for extension of time to file brief filed 
04/29/2011Letter filed 
04/12/2012Motion for extension of time to file reply brief disposedNo action taken on motion
04/11/2011Brief filed - oral argument requested 
04/11/2011Appellants brief due 
03/28/2011Motion for extension of time to file brief disposedGrant motion
03/23/2011Fee paid 
03/22/2011Record checked in 
03/21/2011Motion for extension of time to file brief filed 
03/21/2011Appellants brief due 
03/16/2011Record checked out 
03/15/2013Petition for review filed in Supreme Court 
03/15/2013Petition for review due in Supreme Court 
03/15/2011Record checked in 
03/11/2011Record checked out 
03/07/2011Record checked in 
03/01/2011Record checked out 
02/23/2011Motion for extension of time to file brief disposedGrant motion
02/18/2011Record filed 
02/15/2011Supplemental clerks record filed 
02/14/2011Fee paid 
02/14/2011Motion for extension of time to file brief filed 
02/14/2011Appellants brief due 
02/13/2013Petition for review due in Supreme Court 
02/11/2013Motion for extension of time to file petition for review disposed by Supreme CourtMotion or Writ Granted
02/08/2013Motion for extension of time to file petition for review filed in Supreme Court 
01/30/2012Letter brief filed 
01/11/2013Sent to publisher 
01/09/2012Post submission brief filed 
Calendars
Set Date▲▼Calendar Type▲▼Reason Set▲▼
06/18/2021RetentionDate civil case will be destroyed (6 yrs after mandate)
11/02/2015Case StoredCase stored
Parties
Party▲▼Party Type▲▼Representative▲▼
Controls Solutions, Inc.AppellantGeorge Howard Lugrin
Karen Klaas Milhollin
Jeffrey E. Fahys
Boyd, MarkAppellantJeffrey E. Fahys
Karen Klaas Milhollin
George Howard Lugrin
Gharda Chemical Ltd.AppelleeJohn B. Wallace
Charles W. Lyman
Scott Patterson
United Phosphorus, Inc.AppellantKaren Klaas Milhollin
Jeffrey E. Fahys
George Howard Lugrin
Gharda USA, Inc. AppelleeDavid S. Toy  
James T. Liston
Trial Court Information
55th District Court 
Harris 
Honorable Dion Ramos 
0467993