First Court of Appeals

Case: 01-12-00175-CV    
01-12-00175-CV
02/17/2012
Summary judgment
Kimbley Harold  
Matthew M. Carrick; Carolyn M. Berg, Doan Nguyen, David Chafey 
No 
 
 
 
 
 
Thomson/West 
Appellate Briefs
Date▲▼Event Type▲▼Description▲▼Document
03/19/2013Supplemental brief filedAppellee
07/15/2012Appendix filedAppellee
[ PDF/21.40 MB ] Appendix I-J To Appellee Brief
[ PDF/127 KB ] Cover Letter For Appendix To Appellee Brie
07/15/2012Appendix filedAppellee
[ PDF/1.37 MB ] Cover Letter To Appendix To Appellee Brief
[ PDF/16.74 MB ] Appendix F-G To Appellee Brief
07/15/2012Appendix filedAppellee
[ PDF/20.43 MB ] Appendix D-E Appellee Brief
[ PDF/1.37 MB ] Cover Letter To Appendix D-E Appellee Brief
07/15/2012Appendix filedAppellee
[ PDF/20.65 MB ] Appendix A-C To Appellee Brief
[ PDF/127 KB ] Cover Letter To Appendix A-C Appellee Brief
07/15/2012Electronic brief filed - oral argument not requestedAppellee
07/15/2012Appendix filedAppellee
[ PDF/10.71 MB ] Appendix H To Appellee Brief
[ PDF/1.37 MB ] Cover Letter For Appendix To Appellee Brief
05/16/2012Electronic brief filed - oral argument not requestedAppellant
Case Events
Date▲▼Event Type▲▼Disposition▲▼Document
12/31/2015Mandate issued 
12/22/2015Document filed 
12/18/2015Notice received 
10/29/2013Document filed 
10/25/2013Petition for review filed in Supreme Court 
09/25/2013Motion for rehearing was not filed 
09/25/2013Motion for rehearing due 
09/18/2015Notice received 
09/10/2013Memorandum opinion issuedAffirm TC judgment
[ PDF/272 KB ] Memorandum Opinion
[ PDF/69 KB ] Notice
09/10/2013Judgment Issued 
09/04/2015Petition for review disposed by Supreme CourtSC denies petition for review
08/06/2012Reply brief due 
07/18/2016Notice received 
07/16/2012Appellees brief due 
07/15/2012Appendix filed 
[ PDF/21.40 MB ] Appendix I-J to Appellee Brief
[ PDF/127 KB ] Cover Letter for Appendix to Appellee Brie
07/15/2012Appendix filed 
[ PDF/10.71 MB ] Appendix H to Appellee Brief
[ PDF/1.37 MB ] Cover Letter for Appendix to Appellee Brief
07/15/2012Appendix filed 
[ PDF/1.37 MB ] Cover Letter to Appendix to Appellee Brief
[ PDF/16.74 MB ] Appendix F-G to Appellee Brief
07/15/2012Appendix filed 
[ PDF/20.43 MB ] Appendix D-E Appellee Brief
[ PDF/1.37 MB ] Cover Letter to Appendix D-E Appellee Brief
07/15/2012Appendix filed 
[ PDF/20.65 MB ] Appendix A-C to Appellee Brief
[ PDF/127 KB ] Cover Letter to Appendix A-C Appellee Brief
07/15/2012Electronic brief filed - oral argument not requested 
07/15/2012Case ready to be set 
06/13/2012Record checked out 
06/02/2015Document filed 
05/16/2016Notice filed 
05/16/2012Electronic brief filed - oral argument not requested 
05/16/2012Appellants brief due 
05/07/2015Case forwarded to higher court 
05/07/2012Deadline to conduct mediation 
04/23/2013Submitted 
04/19/2012Motion for extension of time to file brief disposedGrant motion
04/16/2012Appellants brief due 
04/12/2012Motion for extension of time to file brief filed 
04/10/2012Objection to mediation disposedGrant motion
04/06/2012Record checked in 
04/04/2012Record checked out 
04/04/2012Deadline for parties to select mediator 
03/30/2012Mediation objection filed 
03/22/2016Notice filed 
03/21/2012Order withdrawn 
03/21/2012Order enteredMediation
03/20/2012Record due 
03/19/2013Supplemental brief filed 
03/15/2012Clerks record filed 
03/11/2013Set for submission on briefs 
03/05/2012Docketing statement filed 
03/05/2012Court fee due 
03/05/2012Docketing statement due 
02/28/2012Court reporters information sheet sent 
02/27/2012Fax received 
02/17/2012Fee paid 
02/17/2012Notice of appeal filed in trial court 
02/17/2012Notice of appeal received 
02/17/2012Case began in court of appeals 
01/20/2012Judgment signed by trial court judge 
Calendars
Set Date▲▼Calendar Type▲▼Reason Set▲▼
12/31/2015Case StoredCase stored
12/31/2021RetentionDate civil case will be destroyed (6 yrs after mandate)
Parties
Party▲▼Party Type▲▼Representative▲▼
Harold, KimbleyAppellantScot Gibbons Dollinger
Carrick, Matthew M.AppelleePeggy R. Ban
Joanna Walker Raynes
Berg, Carolyn M.AppelleeJoanna Walker Raynes
Chafey, DavidAppelleeJoanna Walker Raynes
Peggy R. Ban
Nguyen, DoanAppelleePeggy R. Ban
Joanna Walker Raynes
Shippers Stevedoring CompanyIntervenorPaul Gregory Preston
Trial Court Information
113th District Court 
Harris 
Honorable Judge 113th District Court 
0965980