Supreme Court

Case: 08-0208    
08-0208
03/13/2008
Multidistrict Litigation
IN RE HURRICANE RITA HOMEOWNERS' CLAIMS 
 
Appellate Briefs
Date▲▼Event Type▲▼Description▲▼RemarksDocument
10/09/2008Multidistrict Litigation Filing Respondent Clarification addressing movants' misrepresentations in movants' response to rsps' motion to vacate (filed by Marialyn Barnard)  -  **Original & copy filed in 08-0142 only and entry entered in 08-0142, 08-0208, and 08-0427**
09/24/2008MDL Response filed Respondent Response to Motion to Stay those District Court Proceedings involving Standard Guaranty Insurance Copmany (filed by Erin Murphy)
09/15/2008Rehearing before the Multidistrict Litigation PanelMovant Movant's Motion for Reconsideration and Clarification (filed by Richard Gateley)
05/14/2008Multidistrict Litigation Filing Respondent Advisory to the Court letting the Panel know that Case No. B177901, Richmond O. Bennett, III v. Voyager Indemnity Insurance Company, et al., filed in the 60th Judicial District Court of Jefferson County, has settled
04/21/2008Exhibits in case/cause filedMovant Exhibits filed per order by MDL Panel issued 4/16/08.  Exhibits include Plf's Original Petition & Request for Disclosure (Cause No. 48,124 - Belinda Roggenkamp, et al. v. Standard Guaranty Ins. Co.)
04/15/2008Multidistrict Litigation Filing Other than Petitioner, Respondent, Relator etc. Post Submission Letter Brief (filed by Marialyn Barnard) **entered and filed in 08-0142**
04/09/2008Multidistrict Litigation supplemental Movant Standard Guaranty Ins. Company, et al's supplemental reply in support of motion to transfer (filed by April Robbins)
04/08/2008Multidistrict Litigation Filing Other than Petitioner, Respondent, Relator etc. Notice of Appearance and Designation of Lead Counsel at Oral Argument (filed by Marialyn Barnard) *filed in MDL 08-0142*
04/08/2008Multidistrict Litigation Reply filedOther than Petitioner, Respondent, Relator etc. Dixie Stewart, Kyle Albright and Southwest Adjusters of Texas, LLC's letter reply (filed by Randal Cashiola)
04/07/2008Multidistrict Litigation Reply filedMovant Standard Guaranty Insurance Company, et al's reply in support of motion to transfer (filed by April Robbins)
04/04/2008MDL Response filed Respondent Response in Opposition to the Insurance Companies' Motion to Transfer Pursuant to Rule 13 (filed by J. Steven Mostyn)
03/13/2008Appendix FiledMovant
03/13/2008Multidistrcit Litigation Motion to TransferMovant Standard Guaranty Insurance Co., et al's Motion to Transfer pursuant to Rule 13 (filed by April Robbins)
Case Events
Date▲▼Event Type▲▼Disposition▲▼RemarksDocument
11/20/2008Document filed (see remarks)  **hard copies of document filed in 08-0142** (Entry entered in 08-0208, 08-0899, & 08-0914) Movant's reply to TWIA's response to emergency motion to stay cases pending the Supreme Court ruling on petition for writ of mandamus (filed by Brendan McBride)
11/12/2008Document received (See Remarks)  **see case no. 08-0142 for hard copy of document** Response of Gary Debbs, et al to Motion to Stay MDL Proceedings pending Supreme  Court ruling of petition for writ of mandamus (document rec'd entry in case no. 08-0208, 08-0914, and 08-0899)
11/07/2008Document filed (see remarks)  Document filed in 08-0142 related to 08-0208, 08-0914 & 08-0899 - Emergency motion to stay cases pending the Supreme Court ruling on petition for writ of mandamus case no. 08-0923
10/13/2008Reply to Response to Motion  Reply to Motion for Reconsideration and Clarification (filed by April Robbins)
10/10/2008Motion to Stay DisposedDenied Motion to Stay those District Court Proceedings involving Standard Guaranty Insurance Company denied
10/10/2008Rehearing before the Multidistrict Litigation Panel disposedDenied Movants' motion for reconsideration and clarification is denied.  All stay orders are withdrawn, and any pending requests for stay are denied.
10/09/2008Multidistrict Litigation Filing   Clarification addressing movants' misrepresentations in movants' response to rsps' motion to vacate (filed by Marialyn Barnard)  -  **Original & copy filed in 08-0142 only and entry entered in 08-0142, 08-0208, and 08-0427**
10/08/2008Per Curiam OpinionIssued pc entered in 08-0142, 08-0208 and 08-0427 (see events and related docs in 08-0142)
10/08/2008Multidistrict Litigation Order sent  Order issued in 08-0142, 08-0208, 08-0427 granting in part and denying in part motion to vacate (filed in 08-0142).  Per Curiam issued in all three cases.
10/02/2008Document filed (see remarks)  **Document filed in control folder for 08-0142** - Response to Motion for Reconsideration and Clarification (filed by Marialyn Barnard)
09/26/2008Document filed (see remarks)  **Document filed in control folder for 08-0142** - Motion to Vacate Order of Appointment of Pretrial Judge (filed by Marialyn Barnard)
09/24/2008MDL Response filed   Response to Motion to Stay those District Court Proceedings involving Standard Guaranty Insurance Copmany (filed by Erin Murphy)
09/19/2008Motion to Stay Filed   Motion to Stay those District Court Proceedings involving Standard Guaranty Insurance Company (filed by Standard Guaranty by April Robbins)
09/15/2008Rehearing before the Multidistrict Litigation Panel  Movant's Motion for Reconsideration and Clarification (filed by Richard Gateley)
09/10/2008Stay Order lifted  Order states:  On May 21, 2008 this Panel extended an order staying proceedings in the cases listed in attached exhibit.  That order is lifted and the stay order is dissolved.
09/10/2008Stay Order lifted  Order lifting stay that states:  On May 21, 2008 this Panel extended an order staying proceedings in the cases listed in attached exhibit.  That order is lifted and the stay order is dissolved.
09/05/2008Multidistrict Litigation Motion to Transfer disposedDenied
09/05/2008Concurring and Dissenting Opinion deliveredIssued Presiding Judge Peeples delivered an opinion concurring in part and dissenting in part, in which Justice McClure joined.
09/05/2008Opinion issuedDenied Justice Hanks delivered the opinion of the Panel, in which Justice Lang and Justice Stone joined.
05/21/2008Stay order lifted in part  The stay is lifted in the Bennett case to allow the parties to present their proposed settlement to the trial court for its review and approval.
05/21/2008Motion to Stay DisposedFiling granted Request for clarification of stay, motion to supplement stay and supplement exhibit granted.  MDL Panel extends stay of cases listed on exhibit submitted 5/1/08 with the following exception:  The stay is lifted in the Bennett case to allow the parties to present their proposed settlement to the trial court for its review and approval.  All trial court proceedings, with exception of Bennett case, are stayed pending further order of this Panel.
05/14/2008Multidistrict Litigation Filing   Advisory to the Court letting the Panel know that Case No. B177901, Richmond O. Bennett, III v. Voyager Indemnity Insurance Company, et al., filed in the 60th Judicial District Court of Jefferson County, has settled
05/01/2008Motion to Stay Filed   Request for Clarification of Stay, Motion to Supplement Stay and Supplement Exhibit (filed by April Robbins)
04/21/2008Exhibits in case/cause filed  Exhibits filed per order by MDL Panel issued 4/16/08.  Exhibits include Plf's Original Petition & Request for Disclosure (Cause No. 48,124 - Belinda Roggenkamp, et al. v. Standard Guaranty Ins. Co.)
04/21/2008Document filed (see remarks)  (Entered and filed in 08-0142) Standard Guranty Insurance Company, et al's Certificate of Compliance in accordance with order of MDL Panel issued April 16, 2008. (April Robbins)
04/21/2008Document filed (see remarks)  (Entered and filed in 08-0142) Standard Guranty Insurance Company, et al's Amended Exhibit.  Movants amended Exhibit "C" to omit two of those cases, Matte Service Corp v. Republic Lloyds, Eric Uhl, Fred L. David and Wachovia and Robert Johnson v. Standard Guaranty Insurance Company.  Movant doesn't believe these two cases are appropriate for tag along. (filed April Robbins)
04/16/2008Document filed (see remarks)  filed in consolidated case 08-0142 - Movants Reply to address respondents' allegations set forth in "untimely post-submission letter brief filed without leave by Respondents' counsel. (April Robbins)
04/16/2008Multidistrict Litigation Order sent  Pursuant to Rule 13.3(j) counsel for movant is ordered to file with the clerk, by 5:00 p.m. on April 23, copies of the following documents:  (1) the Requests for Production and Interrogatories to Delta Lloyds (No. 08-0142) and (2) the petitions and the Requests for Production and Interrogatories to the insurance companies in the Hurricane Rita cases (No. 08-0208).
04/15/2008Multidistrict Litigation Filing   Post Submission Letter Brief (filed by Marialyn Barnard) **entered and filed in 08-0142**
04/09/2008Multidistrict Litigation supplemental   Standard Guaranty Ins. Company, et al's supplemental reply in support of motion to transfer (filed by April Robbins)
04/09/2008MDL Case heard on this date  OA hearing held at Fourth Court of Appeals in San Antonio at 1:30 p.m. (all Judges participated in hearing)
04/08/2008Multidistrict Litigation Filing   Notice of Appearance and Designation of Lead Counsel at Oral Argument (filed by Marialyn Barnard) *filed in MDL 08-0142*
04/08/2008Multidistrict Litigation Reply filed  Dixie Stewart, Kyle Albright and Southwest Adjusters of Texas, LLC's letter reply (filed by Randal Cashiola)
04/07/2008Multidistrict Litigation Reply filed  Standard Guaranty Insurance Company, et al's reply in support of motion to transfer (filed by April Robbins)
04/04/2008MDL Response filed   Response in Opposition to the Insurance Companies' Motion to Transfer Pursuant to Rule 13 (filed by J. Steven Mostyn)
03/27/2008Phone call from Clerk's Office  Call made to parties regarding grant of emergency motion to stay
03/26/2008Stay Order issued  stay of all trial court proceedings in list of cases until further order of the Panel
03/26/2008Motion to Stay DisposedFiling granted Emergency Motion to Stay District court Proceedings granted; All TC proceedings in the attached list of cases are stayed pending further order of the Panel.  Tex. R. Jud. Admin. 13.4(b)
03/26/2008Motion to Stay Filed   Emergency Motion to Stay District court Proceedings (filed by April Robbins)
03/21/2008Supplement to Motion filed  Movants' Supplemental Motion to Stay District Court Proceedings (filed by April Robbins)
03/19/2008Notice setting hearing in Multidistrict Litigation Case  Notice of hearing of MDL case to be held at the Fourth Court of Appeals in San Antonion, Tx on 4/9/08 at 1:30 p.m.; Time allotted to argue:  30/30 minutes (related to 08-0142 - In re Delta Lloyds Ins. Company)
03/19/2008Motion to Stay DisposedDenied Standard Guaranty Ins. Company, et al's motion to stay district court proceedings denied
03/13/2008Motion to Stay Filed   Standard Guaranty Ins. Company, et al's motion to stay district court proceedings (filed by April Robbins)
03/13/2008Appendix Filed 
03/13/2008Multidistrcit Litigation Motion to Transfer  Standard Guaranty Insurance Co., et al's Motion to Transfer pursuant to Rule 13 (filed by April Robbins)
Calendars
Set Date▲▼Calendar Type▲▼Reason Set▲▼Remarks▲▼
No Calendar.
Parties
Party▲▼Party Type▲▼Representative▲▼
STANDARD GUARANTY INSURANCE COMPANYMovantMs. April C. Robbins
JABBAR, RAHIMRespondentMr. John Steven Mostyn
Court of Appeals Information:
 
 
 
 
Trial Court Information