Supreme Court

Case: 15-0360    
15-0360
05/13/2015
Multidistrict Litigation
IN RE FRAUDULENT HOSPITAL LIEN LITIGATION 
 
Appellate Briefs
Date▲▼Event Type▲▼Description▲▼RemarksDocument
08/09/2019MDL Response to Motion for RehearingRespondent Response to Williams' Motion for Rehearing of the MDL Pretrial Court's Order on Remand filed by attorney  Kay Hazelwood
07/25/2019Rehearing before the Multidistrict Litigation Panel  Terrance Williams' Motion for Rehearing of the MDL Pretrial Court's Order on Remand filed by attorney J. Michael Moore
10/25/2017Multidistrict Litigation Filing Other than Petitioner, Respondent, Relator etc. Defendant Alegis Revenue Group, LLC's Notice of Transfer of Tag-Along Case
09/26/2017Multidistrict Litigation Filing   MDL Filing styled, "Defendant Northwest Texas Healthcare System, Inc.'s Original Answer to Plaintiff's First Amended Petition" filed by attorney Douglas Turek
09/26/2017Multidistrict Litigation Filing   MDL document styled, "Defendant Northwest Texas Healthcare System, Inc.'s Motion to Dismiss Under the Texas Citizen's Protection Act filed by attorney Douglas Turek
09/26/2017Multidistrict Litigation Filing   MDL document styled, "Defendant Baptist/St. Anthony's Health System d/b/a BSA Health System's Motion to Dismiss Under the Texas Citizen's Protection Act filed by attorney Douglas Turek
12/20/2016Multidistrict Litigation Filing   Signed Order of Voluntary Recusal Under TRCP 18b(b)(1) and Request for Re-Transfer of all Future Proceedings Pursuant to Rule 13.3(o) of the Rules of Judicial Administration filed by 430th District Court of Hidalgo County, Texas
10/12/2015Multidistrict Litigation Filing Respondent Cardon Healthcare Motion for Summary Judgment as to Statute of Limitations to be filed with Hidalgo County
10/12/2015Multidistrict Litigation Filing Respondent Defendants' Joint Motion for Partial Summary Judgment on "Admitted" as Used in Tex. Prop. Code 55.002(a) filed on behalf of Cardon Healthcare Network, Inc., et al.to be filed with Hidalgo County
10/12/2015Multidistrict Litigation Filing Respondent Cardon Healthcare Network, Inc's Motion for Summary Judgment as to Plaintiffs' Allegations of Fraudulent Liens to be filed with Hidalgo County
08/18/2015MDL Response filed Movant Plaintiffs Response to Motion for Emergency Stay; and Alternative Emergency Request for Appointment of an Interim Pretrial Judge to Hear Plaintiffs Emergency Motion to Compel and for Sanctions filed by The Moore Law Firm
07/14/2015Multidistrict Litigation Filing Respondent McAllen Hospitals, L.P. d/b/a McAllen Medical Center's letter adopting Cardon Healthcare sur-reply filed by attorney Richard A. Sheehy
07/14/2015Multidistrict Litigation Filing Movant Plaintiff/Movant The Moore Law Firm's letter updating the Panel on the state of trial litigation filed by attorney J. Michael Moore
07/09/2015Multidistrict Litigation Filing Respondent Exhibit for Alegis' Motion for Leave to File - "Motion to Adopt, in part, Cardon Healthcare Network, Inc's Sur-Reply in Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motion to Transfer to a Multidistrict Pretrial Court" filed by attorney I. Cecilia Garza
07/01/2015Multidistrict Litigation Filing Respondent Designation of Additional Counsel for Respondent Cardon Healthcare Network, Inc. filed by Sawnie A. McEntire
06/26/2015Multidistrict Litigation Reply filedMovant Reply in Support of Motion to Transfer to Multidistrict Litigation Pretrial Court filed on behalf of The Moore Law Firm Plaintiffs filed by attorney Brandy Wingate Voss
06/19/2015Multidistrict Litigation Filing Respondent Designation of Additional Counsel for Respondent McAllen Hospitals, LP d/b/a McAllen Medical Center filed by attorney Richard Sheehy
06/09/2015MDL Response to Motion for TransferRespondent Respondent Cardon Healthcare Network, Inc.'s Response and Objection to Motion to Transfer to Multidistrict Litigation Pretrial Court filed by attorney Brian P. Casey
06/02/2015Multidistrict Litigation Joinder filedRespondent Respondent Cardon Healthcare Network, Inc.'s Joinder in Respondent Alegis Revenue Group LLC's Response and Objections to Motion to Transfer to Multidistrict Litigation Pretrial Court filed by attorney Brian P. Casey
06/02/2015MDL Response to Motion for TransferRespondent Respondent Alegis Revenue Group LLC's Response and Objections to Motion to Transfer to Mutlidistrict Litigation Pretrial Court filed by attorney I. Cecilia Garza
06/02/2015MDL Response to Motion for TransferRespondent Response to Motion for Transfer to Multdistrict Litigation Pretrial Court filed on behalf of McAllen Hospitals, L.P. d/b/a McAllen Medical Center by attorney Richard Sheehy
05/13/2015Multidistrcit Litigation Motion to TransferMovant Motion for Transfer to Multidistrict Litigation Pretrial Court filed on behalf of The Moore Law Firm
Case Events
Date▲▼Event Type▲▼Disposition▲▼RemarksDocument
09/26/2019Rehearing before the Multidistrict Litigation Panel disposedDenied Motion for Rehearing denied with per curiam opinion
08/09/2019MDL Response to Motion for Rehearing  Response to Williams' Motion for Rehearing of the MDL Pretrial Court's Order on Remand filed by attorney  Kay Hazelwood
07/25/2019Rehearing before the Multidistrict Litigation Panel  Terrance Williams' Motion for Rehearing of the MDL Pretrial Court's Order on Remand filed by attorney J. Michael Moore
10/25/2017Multidistrict Litigation Filing   Defendant Alegis Revenue Group, LLC's Notice of Transfer of Tag-Along Case
10/20/2017Multidistrict Litigation Motion  Defendant Baptist St. Anthony's Health System d/b/a BSA Health System's Motion to Remand filed by Douglas Turek
10/20/2017Multidistrict Litigation Motion  Defendant Northwest Texas Healthcare System, Inc.'s Motion to Remand filed by Douglas Turek
10/20/2017Multidistrict Litigation Motion  Defendant Northwest Texas Healthcare System, Inc.'s Motion to Remand filed by Douglas Turek
09/26/2017Multidistrict Litigation Filing   MDL Filing styled, "Defendant Northwest Texas Healthcare System, Inc.'s Original Answer to Plaintiff's First Amended Petition" filed by attorney Douglas Turek
09/26/2017Multidistrict Litigation Filing   MDL document styled, "Defendant Northwest Texas Healthcare System, Inc.'s Motion to Dismiss Under the Texas Citizen's Protection Act filed by attorney Douglas Turek
09/26/2017Multidistrict Litigation Filing   MDL document styled, "Defendant Baptist/St. Anthony's Health System d/b/a BSA Health System's Motion to Dismiss Under the Texas Citizen's Protection Act filed by attorney Douglas Turek
09/21/2017Multidistrict Litigation notice received  Notice of Transfer of Tag-Along Case filed on behalf of Tomas Garcia and Maria Molina
09/21/2017Multidistrict Litigation notice received  Notice of Transfer of Rule 13.5(e) Tag-Along Case filed on behalf of Awo Hassan Robleh
02/13/2017Appointment of Pretrial Judge   By an order issued on August 21, 2015 the panel appointed the Hon. Israel Ramon, Jr., Judge of the 430th District Court of Hidalgo County, as pretrial judge in the above-captioned case. That order is set aside. The panel hereby appoints the Hon. David Sanchez, Judge of the 444th District Court of Cameron County, as pretrial judge in the above-captioned proceeding and transfers all pending cases, together with any tagalong cases, to him.
01/30/2017Multidistrict Litigation Motion  Motion for Clarification Regarding Assignment of MDL Pretrial Judge and Objection filed on behalf of Universal Health Services, Inc., et al.
12/20/2016Multidistrict Litigation Filing   Signed Order of Voluntary Recusal Under TRCP 18b(b)(1) and Request for Re-Transfer of all Future Proceedings Pursuant to Rule 13.3(o) of the Rules of Judicial Administration filed by 430th District Court of Hidalgo County, Texas
04/12/2016Case Stored  Case e-stored.
10/12/2015Multidistrict Litigation Filing   Cardon Healthcare Motion for Summary Judgment as to Statute of Limitations to be filed with Hidalgo County
10/12/2015Multidistrict Litigation Filing   Defendants' Joint Motion for Partial Summary Judgment on "Admitted" as Used in Tex. Prop. Code 55.002(a) filed on behalf of Cardon Healthcare Network, Inc., et al.to be filed with Hidalgo County
10/12/2015Multidistrict Litigation Filing   Cardon Healthcare Network, Inc's Motion for Summary Judgment as to Plaintiffs' Allegations of Fraudulent Liens to be filed with Hidalgo County
08/21/2015Appointment of Pretrial Judge   Pursuant to Rule 13 of the Texas Rules of Judicial Administration, the cases listed in the Appendix of the Motion for Transfer, and all tag-along cases filed in Hidalgo County, if any, are transferred to Judge Israel Ramon, Jr. of the 430th District Court of Hidalgo County.
(8/21/2015 11:10:24 AM) 15-0360_APPT OF MDL PRETRIAL JUDGE.pdf
08/21/2015Motion before the MDL Panel disposedDismissed Joint Motion to Clarify Scope of MDL for Hidalgo Co. Hospital Lien Litigation dismissed
08/21/2015MDL Motion to Stay disposedDismissed Respondent Alegis Revenue Group, LLC's Motion for Emergency Stay dismissed
08/20/2015Multidistrict Litigation Motion  Joint Motion to Clarify Scope of Order of MDL for Hidalgo County Hospital Lien Litigation
08/18/2015MDL Response filed   Plaintiffs Response to Motion for Emergency Stay; and Alternative Emergency Request for Appointment of an Interim Pretrial Judge to Hear Plaintiffs Emergency Motion to Compel and for Sanctions filed by The Moore Law Firm
08/17/2015Motion to Stay filed before the MDL Panel  Motion to Stay filed on behalf of Respondent Alegis Revenue Group, LLC
08/12/2015Opinion issued by Multidistrict Litigation PanelIssued Justice Harvey Brown delivered the opinion of the MDL Panel.
(8/12/2015 1:18:27 PM) MDL 150360 Opinion Issued.pdf, 150360 - ORDER_ MO TRANSFER GRANTED_08-12-15.pdf
08/12/2015Multidistrict Litigation Order sent  The Moore Law Firm’s motion for transfer under Rule 13 of the Texas Rules of Judicial Administration, filed May 14, 2015, is granted.  All pending motions are denied as moot.  The panel will issue a second order at a later date naming the judge to whom the cases will be transferred.  Justice Harvey Brown delivered the opinion of the MDL panel.
08/12/2015Motion before the MDL Panel disposedFiling dismissed as moot Motion for Leave to Consider Supplemental Appendix dismissed as moot
08/06/2015Response to Motion filed  Response to Movants-Plaintiffs' Motion for Leave to File Evidence in Support of Motion to Transfer Hidalgo County Hospital Lien Litigation.
07/29/2015Multidistrict Litigation Motion  Motion for Leave to Consider Supplemental Appendix Included with Reply Brief filed on behalf of The Moore Law Firm Plaintiffs
07/14/2015Multidistrict Litigation Filing   McAllen Hospitals, L.P. d/b/a McAllen Medical Center's letter adopting Cardon Healthcare sur-reply filed by attorney Richard A. Sheehy
07/14/2015Multidistrict Litigation Filing   Plaintiff/Movant The Moore Law Firm's letter updating the Panel on the state of trial litigation filed by attorney J. Michael Moore
07/10/2015Motion before the MDL Panel disposedFiling granted Motion for Leave to Adopt, in part, Cardon Healthcare Network, Inc.'s Sur-Reply granted
07/09/2015Multidistrict Litigation Filing   Exhibit for Alegis' Motion for Leave to File - "Motion to Adopt, in part, Cardon Healthcare Network, Inc's Sur-Reply in Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motion to Transfer to a Multidistrict Pretrial Court" filed by attorney I. Cecilia Garza
07/09/2015Multidistrict Litigation Motion  Motion for Leave to Adopt, in part, Cardon Healthcare Network, Inc.'s Sur-Reply in Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motion to Transfer to a Multidistrict Pretrial Court filed on behalf of Alegis Revenue Group, LLC by attorney I. Cecilia Garza
07/08/2015Motion before the MDL Panel disposedFiling granted Motion for Leave to File Sur-Reply in Opposition of Plaintiffs' Motion for Transfer granted
07/06/2015Multidistrict Litigation Motion  Motion for Leave to File Sur-Reply in Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motion for Transfer to a Multidistrict Pretrial Court filed on behalf of Respondent Cardon Healthcare Network Inc. by attorney Lori Hanson
07/01/2015Multidistrict Litigation Filing   Designation of Additional Counsel for Respondent Cardon Healthcare Network, Inc. filed by Sawnie A. McEntire
06/26/2015Multidistrict Litigation Reply filed  Reply in Support of Motion to Transfer to Multidistrict Litigation Pretrial Court filed on behalf of The Moore Law Firm Plaintiffs filed by attorney Brandy Wingate Voss
06/19/2015Multidistrict Litigation Filing   Designation of Additional Counsel for Respondent McAllen Hospitals, LP d/b/a McAllen Medical Center filed by attorney Richard Sheehy
06/10/2015Motion before the MDL Panel disposedFiling granted Movants/Plaintiffs' First Opposed Motion for Extension of Time to File Reply in Support of Motion to Transfer granted
06/09/2015MDL Response to Motion for Transfer  Respondent Cardon Healthcare Network, Inc.'s Response and Objection to Motion to Transfer to Multidistrict Litigation Pretrial Court filed by attorney Brian P. Casey
06/09/2015Multidistrict Litigation Motion  Movants/Plaintiffs' First Opposed Motion for Extension of Time to File Reply in Support of Motion to Transfer filed by The Moore Law Firm by attorney J. Michael Moore
06/09/2015Notice of Appearance  Notice of Appearance of Counsel for Movants/Plaintiffs of Brandy Wingate Voss filed by attorney J. Michael Moore
06/03/2015Motion before the MDL Panel disposedFiling granted Respondent Cardon Healthcare Network, Inc.'s Partially Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to File Response to Motion for Transfer to Multidistrict Litigation Pretrial Court granted.  Response due no later than June 9, 2015
06/02/2015MDL Response to Motion for Transfer  Respondent Alegis Revenue Group LLC's Response and Objections to Motion to Transfer to Mutlidistrict Litigation Pretrial Court filed by attorney I. Cecilia Garza
06/02/2015MDL Response to Motion for Transfer  Response to Motion for Transfer to Multdistrict Litigation Pretrial Court filed on behalf of McAllen Hospitals, L.P. d/b/a McAllen Medical Center by attorney Richard Sheehy
06/02/2015Multidistrict Litigation Joinder filed  Respondent Cardon Healthcare Network, Inc.'s Joinder in Respondent Alegis Revenue Group LLC's Response and Objections to Motion to Transfer to Multidistrict Litigation Pretrial Court filed by attorney Brian P. Casey
06/02/2015Multidistrict Litigation Motion  Respondent Cardon Healthcare Network, Inc.'s Partially Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to File Response to Motion for Transfer to Multidistrict Litigation Pretrial Court filed by attorney Brian P. Casey
05/13/2015Multidistrcit Litigation Motion to Transfer  Motion for Transfer to Multidistrict Litigation Pretrial Court filed on behalf of The Moore Law Firm
Calendars
Set Date▲▼Calendar Type▲▼Reason Set▲▼Remarks▲▼
04/12/2016Case StoredCase stored.Case e-stored.
Parties
Party▲▼Party Type▲▼Representative▲▼
Cardon Healthcare Network, Inc.RespondentMs. Lori W. Hanson  
Mr. Sawnie A. McEntire
Mr. D. Todd Parrish
Mr. Brian P. Casey
Alegis Revenue Group, LLCRespondentMs. Ida Cecilia Garza
The Moore Law Firm PlaintiffsMovantMr. D. Todd Smith
Mr. J. Michael Moore
Ms. Brandy Wingate Voss  
McAllen Hospitals, L.P.RespondentMr. Richard A. Sheehy
Mr. Steven M. Gonzalez
SignatureCare Emergency CenterDefendant(s)Ms. Kay J. Hazelwood
Court of Appeals Information:
 
 
 
 
Trial Court Information