Supreme Court

Case: 15-0884    
15-0884
11/17/2015
Multidistrict Litigation
IN RE VOLKSWAGEN CLEAN DIESEL LITIGATION 
 
Appellate Briefs
Date▲▼Event Type▲▼Description▲▼RemarksDocument
01/15/2016Amendment to Multidistrict Litigation filingRespondent El Paso County's First Amended Response to Motion to Transfer and Request for Stay filed by attorney Jo Anne Bernal
01/07/2016Multidistrict Litigation supplemental Respondent Plaintiff Jeffery Butterfield, Antonio Gracia, Daniel Hochman, & William Schroeder's Second Supplemental Opposition to Transfer to MDL filed by attorney Mark McLean
01/06/2016Multidistrict Litigation supplemental Respondent Jeffrey Butterfield, Antonio Gracia, Daniel Hochman, & William Schroeder's First Supplemental Opposition to Transfer MDL filed by attorney Mark McLean
01/05/2016Multidistrict Litigation supplemental Movant Volkswagen Group of America, Inc. and Audi of America, LLC's Notice of Filing Second Supplement to Volkswagen Clean Diesel Litigation Case List and List of Counsel Agreeing and Disagreeing, and Motion to Modify Order Granting Stay filed by attorney Thomas R. Phillips
12/17/2015Multidistrict Litigation Reply filedMovant Volkswagen Group of America, Inc., et al's Reply to All Oppositions filed by attorney Thomas R. Phillips
12/15/2015MDL Response to Motion for TransferRespondent Response to Motion to Transfer and Request for Stay filed on behalf of El Paso County by attorney Benny Agosto, Jr.
12/14/2015MDL Response to Motion for TransferRespondent Plaintiff Jeffery Butterfield & Daniel Hochman's Opposition to Transfer to MDL filed by attorney Mark McLean
12/11/2015Amendment to Multidistrict Litigation filingMovant Volkswagen Group of America, Inc. and Audi of America, LLC's Notice of Filing of Amended Volkswagen Clean Diesel Litigation Case List and List of Counsel Agreeing and Disagreeing, and Motion to Modify Order Granting Stay filed by attorney Thomas R. Phillips
12/07/2015MDL Response to Motion for TransferRespondent Patrick Law Firm Plaintiffs' Response to Volkswagen Group of America, Inc.'s and Audi of America, LLC's Motion to Transfer and Request for Stay filed by attorney Craig Patrick
12/07/2015MDL Response to Motion for TransferRespondent Bexar County Response to Motion to Transfer and Request for Stay filed by attorney Nicholas LaHood
12/07/2015MDL Response to Motion for TransferRespondent Plaintiff William Schroeder, Antonia Gracia, Jeffery Butterfield & Daniel Hochman's Opposition to Transfer to MDL filed by attorney Neema Amini
12/07/2015MDL Response to Motion for TransferRespondent State's Response to Motion to Transfer State's Consumer Protection Enforcement Action filed by attorney Patrick Sweeten
12/07/2015MDL Response to Motion for TransferRespondent Harris County Response to Motion to Transfer and Request for Stay filed by Richard Mithoff
12/07/2015MDL Response to Motion for Transfer  State of Texas's Response to Defendants' Motion to Transfer Environmental Enforcement Cases filed by attorney Patrick Sweeten
12/04/2015MDL Response to Motion for TransferRespondent Response in Opposition to Motion to Transfer and Request for Stay filed on behalf of Charles Kinsey, Barbara Kinsey, and Tyson Muenich
11/17/2015Multidistrcit Litigation Motion to TransferMovant Motion to Transfer and Request for Stay filed on behalf of Volkswagen Group of America, Inc. by attorney Thomas R. Phillips
Case Events
Date▲▼Event Type▲▼Disposition▲▼RemarksDocument
12/23/2021Multidistrict Litigation Motion  Volkswagen Group of America, Inc., et al.'s Unopposed Motion to Amend MDL Order filed by attorney William S. Snyder
12/17/2015Multidistrict Litigation Reply filed  Volkswagen Group of America, Inc., et al's Reply to All Oppositions filed by attorney Thomas R. Phillips
12/15/2015MDL Response to Motion for Transfer  Response to Motion to Transfer and Request for Stay filed on behalf of El Paso County by attorney Benny Agosto, Jr.
12/14/2015MDL Response to Motion for Transfer  Plaintiff Jeffery Butterfield & Daniel Hochman's Opposition to Transfer to MDL filed by attorney Mark McLean
12/11/2015Amendment to Multidistrict Litigation filing  Volkswagen Group of America, Inc. and Audi of America, LLC's Notice of Filing of Amended Volkswagen Clean Diesel Litigation Case List and List of Counsel Agreeing and Disagreeing, and Motion to Modify Order Granting Stay filed by attorney Thomas R. Phillips
12/07/2015MDL Response to Motion for Transfer  Patrick Law Firm Plaintiffs' Response to Volkswagen Group of America, Inc.'s and Audi of America, LLC's Motion to Transfer and Request for Stay filed by attorney Craig Patrick
12/07/2015MDL Response to Motion for Transfer  Bexar County Response to Motion to Transfer and Request for Stay filed by attorney Nicholas LaHood
12/07/2015MDL Response to Motion for Transfer  Plaintiff William Schroeder, Antonia Gracia, Jeffery Butterfield & Daniel Hochman's Opposition to Transfer to MDL filed by attorney Neema Amini
12/07/2015MDL Response to Motion for Transfer  State's Response to Motion to Transfer State's Consumer Protection Enforcement Action filed by attorney Patrick Sweeten
12/07/2015MDL Response to Motion for Transfer  Harris County Response to Motion to Transfer and Request for Stay filed by Richard Mithoff
12/07/2015Multidistrict Litigation Motion  State of Texas's Motion to Dissolve or Modify the Stay of Environmental Enforcement Cases filed by attorney Patrick Sweeten
12/07/2015MDL Response to Motion for Transfer  State of Texas's Response to Defendants' Motion to Transfer Environmental Enforcement Cases filed by attorney Patrick Sweeten
12/07/2015Motion to Stay filed before the MDL Panel  State of Texas' Request for Relief from Order Granting Motion to Stay State's Consumer Protection Enforcement Action filed by attorney Patrick K. Sweeten
12/04/2015MDL Response to Motion for Transfer  Response in Opposition to Motion to Transfer and Request for Stay filed on behalf of Charles Kinsey, Barbara Kinsey, and Tyson Muenich
11/23/2015MDL Motion to Stay disposedFiling granted Defendants' Volkswagen Group of America, Inc., et al.'s Request for Stay granted.
(11/23/2015 4:34:21 PM) 15-0884_MDL MO TO STAY_GRANTED.pdf
11/17/2015Motion to Stay filed before the MDL Panel  Request for Immediate Stay filed on behalf of Volkswagen Group of America, Inc. filed by attorney Thomas R. Phillips
11/17/2015Multidistrcit Litigation Motion to Transfer  Motion to Transfer and Request for Stay filed on behalf of Volkswagen Group of America, Inc. by attorney Thomas R. Phillips
04/15/2016Case Stored  Case e-stored.
02/11/2021Appointment of Pretrial Judge   Judge Sulak has retired from the bench and has decided not to return to private practice. Therefore, The Panel on Multi-District Litigation has decided to assign Judge Sulak, a retired district judge, as the pretrial judge in both cases and to designate the 200th District Court as the pretrial court for both the Governmental Entity MDL and the Consumer MDL.
(2/11/2021 2:11:52 PM) 15-0884 - APPT OF MDL PRETRIAL JUDGE - 02-11-21.pdf
01/26/2022Motion before the MDL Panel disposedFiling granted Order Issued stating: "IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED that the MDL Order of January 19, 2016 is amended to include the cases listed in the Motion to Transfer as well as the cases listed in the Motion to Amend, and the MDL Order of Transfer will now include not only cases brought by governmental entities against VW America as described in the Motion to Transfer but also the cases brought by VW America against governmental entities regarding alleged violations of the Texas Clean Air Act as described in the Motion to Amend, as well as all tag-along cases."
01/19/2016Appointment of Pretrial Judge   Pursuant to Rule 13 of the Texas Rules of Judicial Administration, the cases brought by governmental entities complaining of violations of the Texas Clean Air Act, and any tag-along cases filed by governmental entities are transferred to Judge Tim Sulak of the 353rd District Court of Travis County.
01/15/2016Amendment to Multidistrict Litigation filing  El Paso County's First Amended Response to Motion to Transfer and Request for Stay filed by attorney Jo Anne Bernal
01/14/2016Opinion issued by Multidistrict Litigation PanelIssued Justice Harvey Brown delivered the unanimous opinion of the MDL panel.  Presiding Judge Peeples, Chief Justice McClure and Justice Puryear concur.  Justice Lang-Miers did not participate.
01/14/2016Multidistrict Litigation Motion to Transfer disposedFiling granted Volkswagen Group of America, Inc. and Audi of America, LLC’s motion to transfer under Rule 13 of the Texas Rules of Judicial Administration, filed November 17, 2015, is granted. All pending motions are dismissed as moot. The panel will issue a second order at a later date naming the judge to whom the cases will be transferred.
Justice Harvey Brown delivered the opinion of the MDL panel.
Justice Lang-Miers did not participate.

(1/14/2016 4:46:06 PM) 15-0884 OPINION Volkwagen final.pdf, 15-0884 - ORDER_ MO TRANSFER GRANTED_09-14-16.pdf
01/14/2016Motion before the MDL Panel disposedFiling dismissed as moot State of Texas's Motion to Dissolve or Modify the Stay of Environmental Enforcement Cases dismissed as moot
01/12/2022MDL Notice of Submission  Notice of Submission: The Unopposed Motion to Amend Multidistrict Litigation Order will be submitted to the Multidistrict Litigation Panel on January 21, 2022.
(1/12/2022 11:20:40 AM) 15-0884 Notice of Submission 01-12-22.pdf
01/07/2021Multidistrict Litigation notice received  Letter from the Supreme Court of Texas to Judge Evans stating: "Pursuant to Administrative Rule 13.6(a) and effective January 1, 2021, the Honorable Tim Sulak, retired district judge, is authorized to serve as a pretrial judge upon assignment by the Panel on Multi-District Litigation in the above-referenced case."
01/07/2016Multidistrict Litigation supplemental   Plaintiff Jeffery Butterfield, Antonio Gracia, Daniel Hochman, & William Schroeder's Second Supplemental Opposition to Transfer to MDL filed by attorney Mark McLean
01/06/2016Multidistrict Litigation supplemental   Jeffrey Butterfield, Antonio Gracia, Daniel Hochman, & William Schroeder's First Supplemental Opposition to Transfer MDL filed by attorney Mark McLean
01/05/2016Multidistrict Litigation supplemental   Volkswagen Group of America, Inc. and Audi of America, LLC's Notice of Filing Second Supplement to Volkswagen Clean Diesel Litigation Case List and List of Counsel Agreeing and Disagreeing, and Motion to Modify Order Granting Stay filed by attorney Thomas R. Phillips
Calendars
Set Date▲▼Calendar Type▲▼Reason Set▲▼Remarks▲▼
04/15/2016Case StoredCase stored. 
Parties
Party▲▼Party Type▲▼Representative▲▼
Volkswagen Group of America, Inc.MovantMr. William Sandy Snyder
Mr. C. Vernon Hartline Jr.
Alford, MaryRespondentMr. Craig M. Patrick
Court of Appeals Information:
 
 
 
 
Trial Court Information