Fifteenth Court of Appeals

Case: 15-24-00029-CV    
15-24-00029-CV
08/28/2024
Declaratory judgment
Ex Parte The City of Irving Texas 
 
No 
5th Court of Appeals 
08/28/2024 
05-23-01100-CV 
 
 
www.txcourts.gov/15thcoa 
Appellate Briefs
Date▲▼Event Type▲▼Description▲▼Document
04/09/2024Reply brief filedAppellant
[ PDF/344 KB ] Appellant Reply Brief
[ PDF/93 KB ] Notice
02/28/2024Brief filed - oral argument requestedAppellee
[ PDF/463 KB ] Appellee Brief
[ PDF/93 KB ] Notice
01/09/2024Brief filed - oral argument requestedAppellant
[ PDF/1.63 MB ] Appellant'S Brief
[ PDF/93 KB ] Notice
Case Events
Date▲▼Event Type▲▼Disposition▲▼Document
11/25/2025Mandate issuedREVERSED AND RENDERED
10/24/2025Petition for review disposed by Supreme CourtDENIED
04/04/2025Petition for review filed in Supreme Court 
[ PDF/42 KB ] Pet filed
04/04/2025Petition for review due in Supreme Court 
[ PDF/63 KB ] 2nd EXT Granted PET REV
[ PDF/41 KB ] 2nd MT EXT PET REV
[ PDF/55 KB ] MT EXT GRT
[ PDF/40 KB ] Mt EXT PET
02/07/2025Corrected pages to opinion issued 
[ PDF/227 KB ] Opinion Corrected
[ PDF/151 KB ] Notice
12/19/2024Judgment Issued 
12/19/2024Memorandum opinion issuedREVERSED AND RENDERED
[ PDF/227 KB ] Memorandum Opinion
[ PDF/151 KB ] Notice
12/05/2024Submitted 
11/12/2024Set for submission on briefs - oral argument denied 
10/29/2024Submission cancelled 
10/23/2024Confirmation of oral argument & counsel presenting oral argument 
[ PDF/209 KB ] OA Confirmation
10/21/2024Corrected entry made by clerks office 
10/09/2024Submission cancelled 
10/09/2024Motion to reset oral argument disposedGRANTED
10/07/2024Motion to reset oral argument filed 
10/02/2024Corrected entry made by clerks office 
09/03/2024Case transferred to this court from another court of appeals 
08/28/2024Case transferred from this court to another court of appealsGRANTED
04/09/2024Reply brief due 
04/09/2024Reply brief filed 
[ PDF/344 KB ] Appellant Reply Brief
[ PDF/93 KB ] Notice
03/13/2024Motion for extension of time to file reply brief disposedGRANTED
[ PDF/102 KB ] Order on Appellant Motion Extension Reply Brief
[ PDF/82 KB ] Notice
03/12/2024Motion for extension of time to file reply brief filed 
[ PDF/136 KB ] Appellant's Motion for Extension to file Reply Brief
02/28/2024Letter filed 
[ PDF/212 KB ] Vacation Letter
02/28/2024Appellees brief due 
02/28/2024Brief filed - oral argument requested 
[ PDF/463 KB ] Appellee Brief
[ PDF/93 KB ] Notice
02/28/2024Case ready to be set 
01/29/2024Appellees brief due 
01/22/2024Order enteredGRANTED
[ PDF/127 KB ] Order Granting Appellee's Motion for Extension to file Brief
[ PDF/82 KB ] Notice
01/17/2024Motion for extension of time to file brief filed 
[ PDF/105 KB ] Appellee'e Motion for Extension to file Brief
01/09/2024Appellants brief due 
01/09/2024Brief filed - oral argument requested 
[ PDF/1.63 MB ] Appellant's Brief
[ PDF/93 KB ] Notice
12/20/2023Appellants brief due 
12/14/2023Order enteredGRANTED
[ PDF/103 KB ] Order on Appellant Motion Extension Brief
[ PDF/82 KB ] Notice
12/12/2023Motion for extension of time to file brief filed 
[ PDF/114 KB ] Appellant’s Motion for Extension to file Brief
12/06/2023Electronic Supplemental Clerks Record Filed 
12/01/2023Letter issued by the court 
12/01/2023Electronic Supplemental Clerks Record Filed 
11/30/2023Electronic Clerks Record Filed 
11/28/2023Reporters record due 
11/20/2023Electronic Reporter/Recorders Record Filed 
11/20/2023Response filed 
[ PDF/1.24 MB ] Letter - regarding supplemental request
11/20/2023Letter issued by the court 
[ PDF/107 KB ] Letter to Attorney General Regarding Reporter Record
[ PDF/81 KB ] Notice
11/14/2023Order enteredGRANTED
[ PDF/76 KB ] Order Granting Court Reporter Extension to File Record
[ PDF/82 KB ] Notice
11/13/2023No clerks record filed in civil case 
11/13/2023Extension of time to file reporters record filed 
[ PDF/112 KB ] Extension Request - no payment
11/11/2023Record due 
11/10/2023Notice received 
11/10/2023Docketing statement filed 
11/10/2023Appearance of counsel 
[ PDF/124 KB ] Appearance of Counsel
11/03/2023Letter issued by the court 
11/03/2023Docketing statement due 
11/02/2023Notice of appeal filed in court of appeals 
11/02/2023Fee paid 
11/01/2023Notice of appeal filed in trial court 
11/01/2023Case began in court of appeals 
10/16/2023Judgment signed by trial court judge 
Calendars
Set Date▲▼Calendar Type▲▼Reason Set▲▼
11/25/2025Case StoredCase stored
11/25/2031RetentionDate civil case will be destroyed (6 yrs after mandate)
Parties
Party▲▼Party Type▲▼Representative▲▼
The City of Irving, TexasAppelleeKaylee R. Henson
Andrea Broyles
Jeffrey L. Oldham
Jacqueline A. Garza-Rothrock
Janet M. Spugnardi
Matthew G. Nielsen
Texas Comptroller of Public AccountsAppellantLynn E. Saarinen
Hegar, GlennAppellantRance L. Craft
Trial Court Information
192nd District Court 
Dallas 
Honorable Maria Aceves 
DC-10-11029 
Tenesa Shaw