Supreme Court

Case: 25-0616    
25-0616
07/15/2025
Multidistrict Litigation
IN RE HOTARD COACHES, INC., ET AL. LITIGATION 
 
Appellate Briefs
Date▲▼Event Type▲▼Description▲▼RemarksDocument
02/03/2026Multidistrict Litigation letter receivedIntervenor Letter to MDL Panel regarding status of appointed judge from The Hall Law Group, PLLC
11/25/2025Multidistrict Litigation Filing   Hotard Defendants' Notice of Tagalong CaseDefendants Hotard Coaches, Inc., et al.'s Notice of Tag-Along Case (Jeffrey Moore) filed by attorney Karen Nennett
10/13/2025Multidistrict Litigation Filing   Letter stating: "On September 9, 2025, Schwanda Sherman, Industrial Bus Lines, Inc., All Aboard America! Holdings, Inc., and Hotard Coaches, Inc. (collectively, “Hotard Defendants”) requested a stay of Martin Luna v. Schwanda Sherman, Industrial Bus Lines, Inc., All Aboard America! Holdings, Inc., and Hotard Coaches, Inc., Cause No. 25DCCV1305, in the 58th Judicial District of Jefferson County, Texas. Plaintiff Martin Luna has sent written discovery to the Hotard
Defendants in that cause. The Hotard Defendants request a ruling on their Motion to Stay, which is on file with the MDL Panel (filed September 9, 2025)."
08/19/2025Multidistrict Litigation Reply filedMovant Reply in Response to Motion to Transfer filed on behalf of Defendants Hotard Coaches, Inc., All Aboard America! Holdings, Inc., Schwanda Sherman, Patti Hall, and Guy Williams by attorney Karen Bennett.
08/04/2025MDL Response to Motion for TransferRespondent Rodriguez Plaintiffs' Adoption and Joinder of Response to Motion to Transfer filed by attorney Adam Lewis
08/04/2025MDL Response to Motion for TransferRespondent Response to Motion for Transfer and Request for Stay filed on behalf of the Ferguson Law Firm filed by attorney Mark Sparks
08/04/2025MDL Response to Motion for TransferRespondent Response to Motion to Transfer filed on behalf of Yeates Plaintiffs by attorney Tommy Yeates
07/19/2025MDL Response to Motion for TransferRespondent Response to Motion to Transfer and Request for Stay filed on behalf of  Plaintiffs Miguel Salazar, Lazaro Vasquez, Josehua Bourgeois, Jose Banda, Armando Ortiz, Anthony Rosati, Johnathan Sanchez, and Arturo Almanzan by attorney Joseph Stephens, Jr.
07/15/2025Multidistrcit Litigation Motion to TransferMovant Motion to Transfer filed on behalf of Defendants Hotard Coaches, Inc., All Aboard America! Holdings, Inc., Schwanda Sherman, Patti Hall, and Guy Williams by attorney Karen Bennett
Case Events
Date▲▼Event Type▲▼Disposition▲▼RemarksDocument
02/25/2026Appointment of Pretrial Judge   Order Issued stating: "The Panel now designates the Pretrial Court as the 60th Judicial District Court in Jefferson County, Texas, and the Panel assigns Judge Michael Mayes as the Pretrial Judge."
(2/25/2026 3:52:50 PM) 25-0616 MDL Appointment of Pretrial Judge and Court 02-25-26.pdf
02/09/2026Electronic communication received from Party  Email received from MDL Panel Chair, Presiding Judge David Evans, stating: "Pursuant to Tex. R. Jud. Admin. 13.6(a) the Panel on Multi-District Litigation requests that the Honorable Michael Mayes, Senior Judge of 410th District Court of Montgomery County, be authorized to serve as a pretrial judge in the above-referenced case upon assignment by the Panel on Multi-District Litigation."
02/03/2026Multidistrict Litigation letter received  Letter to MDL Panel regarding status of appointed judge from The Hall Law Group, PLLC
11/25/2025Multidistrict Litigation Filing   Hotard Defendants' Notice of Tagalong CaseDefendants Hotard Coaches, Inc., et al.'s Notice of Tag-Along Case (Jeffrey Moore) filed by attorney Karen Nennett
10/29/2025Multidistrict Litigation Motion to Transfer disposedFiling granted Motion to Transfer granted.  "The Panel will issue a second order designating the Pretrial Court and assigned Judge. We direct that notice of this Order be sent to the attorneys of record, the trial courts, and clerks of the respective Courts. We extend the stay previously granted to include the Luna Case, and we notify the parties that the stay will be lifted upon the designation of the Pretrial Court and the assigned judge."
10/20/2025Call received  Call received about the status of the pending Moton to Stay.  Contacted MDL Panel to follow up.  
10/13/2025Multidistrict Litigation Filing   Letter stating: "On September 9, 2025, Schwanda Sherman, Industrial Bus Lines, Inc., All Aboard America! Holdings, Inc., and Hotard Coaches, Inc. (collectively, “Hotard Defendants”) requested a stay of Martin Luna v. Schwanda Sherman, Industrial Bus Lines, Inc., All Aboard America! Holdings, Inc., and Hotard Coaches, Inc., Cause No. 25DCCV1305, in the 58th Judicial District of Jefferson County, Texas. Plaintiff Martin Luna has sent written discovery to the Hotard
Defendants in that cause. The Hotard Defendants request a ruling on their Motion to Stay, which is on file with the MDL Panel (filed September 9, 2025)."
09/09/2025Multidistrict Litigation notice received  Notice of Related MDL Cases filed on behalf of Defendants Schwanda Sherman, All Aboard America! Holdings, Inc., and Hotard Coaches, Inc. (collectively, “Hotard Defendants”)
08/19/2025Multidistrict Litigation Reply filed  Reply in Response to Motion to Transfer filed on behalf of Defendants Hotard Coaches, Inc., All Aboard America! Holdings, Inc., Schwanda Sherman, Patti Hall, and Guy Williams by attorney Karen Bennett.
08/04/2025MDL Response to Motion for Transfer  Rodriguez Plaintiffs' Adoption and Joinder of Response to Motion to Transfer filed by attorney Adam Lewis
08/04/2025MDL Response to Motion for Transfer  Response to Motion to Transfer filed on behalf of Yeates Plaintiffs by attorney Tommy Yeates
08/04/2025MDL Response to Motion for Transfer  Response to Motion for Transfer and Request for Stay filed on behalf of the Ferguson Law Firm filed by attorney Mark Sparks
07/21/2025MDL Motion to Stay disposedFiling granted Order issued: "Defendants Hotard Coaches, Inc., All Aboard America! Holdings, Inc., Schwanda Sherman, Patti Hall, and Guy Williams filed a Motion to Transfer & Request For Stay on July 15, 2025 (hereinafter the Motion to Transfer). In the Motion to Transfer the Defendants requested a stay of all trial court proceedings pending the consideration by the MDL Panel of the Motion to Transfer. The Motion to Stay is granted. All trial court proceedings in the cases listed in the Appendix to the Motion to Transfer are stayed until further order of the MDL Panel."
07/19/2025MDL Response to Motion for Transfer  Response to Motion to Transfer and Request for Stay filed on behalf of  Plaintiffs Miguel Salazar, Lazaro Vasquez, Josehua Bourgeois, Jose Banda, Armando Ortiz, Anthony Rosati, Johnathan Sanchez, and Arturo Almanzan by attorney Joseph Stephens, Jr.
07/15/2025Motion to Stay filed before the MDL Panel  Request for Stay incorporated within Motion to Transfer filed on behalf of Defendants Hotard Coaches, Inc., All Aboard America! Holdings, Inc., Schwanda Sherman, Patti Hall, and Guy Williams by attorney Karen Bennett
07/15/2025Multidistrcit Litigation Motion to Transfer  Motion to Transfer filed on behalf of Defendants Hotard Coaches, Inc., All Aboard America! Holdings, Inc., Schwanda Sherman, Patti Hall, and Guy Williams by attorney Karen Bennett
Calendars
Set Date▲▼Calendar Type▲▼Reason Set▲▼Remarks▲▼
No Calendar.
Parties
Party▲▼Party Type▲▼Representative▲▼
Hall, PattiMovantMs. Karen R. Bennett
Williams, GuyMovantMs. Karen R. Bennett
Sherman, SchwandaMovantMs. Karen R. Bennett
Hotard Coaches, Inc.MovantMs. Karen R. Bennett
MDL PlaintiffsRespondentMr. Byron Alfred
Mr. Kurt B. Arnold
Mr. Tommy L. Yeates
Mr. Mark C. Sparks
Mr. Steven J. Kherkher
All Aboard America! Holdings, Inc.MovantMs. Karen R. Bennett
Valerie Lewis
Court of Appeals Information:
 
 
 
 
Trial Court Information